My Favorite Candy Alternatives for Halloween

Halloween is such a fun time of year. I have such fond memories from my childhood. In the tiny town I grew up in, Halloween was truly magical. The entire town attended a Halloween Carnival filled with booths, like Apple Bobbing, Donuts on a String, Cake Walks, Fish Ponds…etc. After the carnival, we would go Trick or Treating. Some neighbors put together spook alleys that lead to their front door, others gave out King Size Candy Bars. I’ll be one of those neighbors… one day… Except for the King Size Candy Bar part. Don’t tell my mom, this is her THING. I don’t know what it is but at some point, it became apart of my nature to not give out candy, and I LOVE candy, like to the CORE. But it did. I felt the need to give out candy alternatives. Maybe it has to do with me being Gluten Free and feeling for those treaters that only hit teal pumpkin houses, or maybe it’s my inability to control myself from taking an extremely aggressive parent candy tax so my sub-conscious is just trying to protect my waistline. Whatever it is, every year Halloween rolls around I’m on the lookout for a fun Candy-alternative, despite my husband being sure it will only encourage the tricksters to egg our house… hasn’t happened yet… so I’m counting these a success. Make sure to check out the free digital download that can be paired with Wiki Stix! Add these to a cellophane bag and you have a great gift | handout for students, classmates, or neighbors!


Also, keep in mind that in order to be worn that way you will have to hand out a connector as well. I did this by simply having the Glow Sticks in one bowl and the connectors in another. I had to share a couple of fun pictures from our first Trunk or Treat. The Glow sticks were a hit, so were our Little Red Riding Hood Costumes and Trunk or Treat!

2. Wikki Stix: I LOVE Wiki Stix. This is an example of an extremely simple concept that just spurs extremely CREATIVE children. If you’ve never heard of them they are simply a piece of yarn dipped in a “special non-toxic, food-grade microcrystalline wax, the kind used in bubblegum and lipsticks. They do not contain gluten, latex, nor peanut or other nut oils or byproducts. Wikki Stix are an excellent product for children dealing with allergies!”  These are SO FUN. They adhere to each other and can be built up and molded, and used over and over again. These are one of my Go-To church toys|Quiet Toys, and PERFECT for any age. As a way to save a little money instead of purchasing the ready-made Halloween packs, I purchased the bulk pack and then individually placed sections of the wiki stix in cellophane bags with a

FREE digital download you can get here!

halloween Just make sure you are logged in or a member of On Lemon Lane. Access to this FREE Download and others is EXCLUSIVE to On Lemon Lanve members. Not a member? No problem! Sign up is FREE & easy peasy Lemon Squeezy. Click here to become a member. These were a hit, and you get SO MANY with the bulk order, great bang for your buck. I’ve been able to use these for two years in a row.


Click Here to Download the FREE Halloween Download


3. Make A Monster Kit: It’s tough to pick a favorite but these build your own monster kits are definitely at the top of my list! These work great as a Halloween class party handout or carnival prizes or even a student gift. You may be catching on that anything that encourages creative play really strikes a chord with me. These kits are SO FUN. You can purchase the instant and EDITABLE download here. This file is through Google slides and all of the text is editable. Even better, you don’t have to worry about finding|spending money on cellophane bags. Instead, I’ve sized these to fit on top of SANDWICH ZIPLOCK Baggies. Making these extremely convenient!


To use simply:

  1. Purchase the EDITABLE, Instant download here.
  2. Edit the text through Google Slides, and print!
  3. Cut out and fold in half
  4. Fill your Ziplocks with playdough, googly eyes, pom-poms, and pipe cleaners…etc
  5. Staple your folded label to the ziplock bag.
  6. Be all EXTRA, without all the EXTRA.


4. “Create Your Own________ Sticker Sheets”: This is on the docket for this year. My kids LOVE stickers. These are so fun and become a perfect Halloween activity that they can work on and enjoy while they enjoy their treats! You have a lot of options from Jack-O-Lanterns to Monsters, to your classic Halloween characters. The best part they are extremely inexpensive! These are perfect to give to students, or neighbors and make the perfect Halloween Class Activity! We did this for a preschool Halloween party and they were a hit!


5. Halloween Rubber Duckies: Stumbled across these and saved them to my cart for the future! Love this as a class handout for Halloween. These are so fun and they GLOW IN THE DARK. I don’t know of a kid that doesn’t love a classic Rubber Duckie! Keep in mind these do have latex. 


6. Punching Balloons: Another fun idea I’ve saved for another year. Kids of all ages LOVE balloons, especially a balloon with a rubber band attached to one end. These are so fun, and even come packaged specifically for Halloween. Again, keep in mind these do have latex. 


7. Halloween Masks: These are great and so appropriate and festive for Halloween! You have a couple of different options from foam masks, to build your own craft masks, to scratch off and decorate masks! Again I love a Halloween handout that has an activity built-in or associated that encourages creative play so these were perfect!


8. Flying Toys: This is another category that has a lot of fun options with price levels that can make anyone’s budget happy! I LOVE the LED Rocket Copters. Be aware if a listing says 24 pieces, it likely means 12 individual rockets, not 24. We’ve played with these and they are unbelievable… Especially at night! The flinging frogs are a great handout that are perfect to be paired with a Witch’s cauldron. Lots of fun options here that are sure to please.


9. Wearable Halloween Headpieces: These are SO cute. For the younger grades, these would be an absolute HOMERUN. These headbands are balloons and could not be any cuter. If you do go this route remember that you need a balloon pump in order to blow these up. SO inexpensive and SO fun.

10. Glow in the Dark Room Stickers

You know the fun glow in the dark stars you attached to your ceiling as a kid?! YES. I wasn’t sure how these would be received but they were a hit! I ran out of these before I ran our of Glow Sticks! These are fun because they come in a lot of different shape options besides just stars. For our Frozen themed Halloween, we handed out Snowflakes! I stuffed 4-5 of these in a small self-sealing cellophane bag with a piece of tik-tak. I was skeptical that the effort wouldn’t be worth the reward. I was pleasantly surprised that we were able to knock-out these fun little handouts in NO-TIME. All were assembled within 15 minutes! I’ll link the exact products we used that were extremely cost-effective and SO fun. Don’t mind my terrible picture. I was letting these “Charge” before our Trunk or Treat and this was the only picture I was able to snag in the rush of things!

Click here to see our Frozen Themed Trunk or Treat (Seriously, it exceeded my expectation)

Click here to see out DIYish Frozen Family Halloween Costumes

That’s my list for now! I would love to come back and add YOUR favorites. What are your favorite non-candy alternatives to candy to hand out on Halloween? What about student gifts or prizes for class parties? Comment below!



This popped up in my memories and I can’t even handle it! 2 years ago. 2 years ago seems like it was just yesterday. 2 years ago feels like a lifetime. So much has changed. So much is the same. How has it already been 2 years! ...

51 1

Anybody else going a little stir crazy with this #everlastingwinter ❄️ I’ve never longed for warmer weather like I am right now! Today we decided to put the snow to use👊🏻 have you ever made Snow Cream??? Literally what childhood dreams are made of. Did I mention those dreams are only made out of 4 ingredients that you can find in your kitchen on any given day. Check out the blog post or highlight story for kore information! ****Also, should add I enjoy this treat just as much, if not more than my toddlers. It’s shockingly delightful💛 ...

53 3

Seriously nothing better than getting pictures of my products in use! Can you even handle how perfect the @safariltd Toob animals are for this free printable?! I love that they offer such a variety! I spy an elk..... if you’re wanting to use this printable but realized you’re no longer within the #primeshipping timeline. You still have options! Hit up your closest @hobbylobby like @katie_m_lemon did! ...

31 1

T-minus one day till Valentine’s Day! Who’s ready?? I’m still trying to figure out what to do for my loved ones.... Remember, these templates and others are available for free download on the website! I’d love to start some fun new traditions, what do you do for Valentine’s Day?? ...

29 5

FREE #valentinesday printable hitting the website TONIGHT! I am so excited with how these turned out❤️❤️❤️ Lots of fun options: friendship bracelets, animal figures, even SEED PAPER. Yes, you literally plant those little paper hearts and wildflowers will sprout and bloom😍 Details and free download coming soon, stay tuned! ...

29 8

Made it to Magnolia and we’re all pretty stoked about it!! Beautiful details, friends and family, and yummy GF options, see story for details💕 Any tips or other places to stop while in Waco? ...

217 18

I spy DIY Toddler proof Mickey Ears.... This fun craft literally took less than 5 minutes and was a HIT for the entire trip! Details coming soon💕 ...

38 6

Can’t wait to share the Traveling with Toddler Tips Series that will be hitting the blog soon. We do our fair share of traveling each year. Which means we’ve made the mistakes, and perfected the art for you! Would love to hear any tips you have to share! ...

35 6

Some people just can’t hang... #disneyland Make sure to check out the latest blog post for all things, tips, tricks, and travel with toddlers! If you are planning a trip to Disneyland or plan to travel with #twoundertwo I’ve got you👊🏻 ...

71 4

Looking for a fun and practical neighbor, friend, or coworker gift? @eosproducts is always well received! Download this cute and FREE printable at
Simply cut out the center ornament and secure the Eos container 💕

16 4

Baby boy’s face melts me in this picture. This time of year is magical ❄️ and being able to experience it through the eyes of these little babes is truly a blessing. Blog post featuring ideas of how to have a more family centered Christmas is coming soon! 🦌🌲🎅🏼🦌🌲🎅🏼🦌🎅🏼🦌🌲🎅🏼 ...

51 1

My boys. My heart could explode. Baby boy is no longer a baby and is quick to refute the idea of him always being my baby boy. This kid is one and only. Full of fire, full of life, full of mischief, and full of compassion. He is a walking contradiction, and smart as a whip. He is funny, and kind, and a whirlwind. He can identify animals you or I have never heard of, and carry the sweetest tune. He is fearless, confident and has such an unbelievable tolerance for pain. Yet something as harmless as a cow or a dog can make him come unglued. We love this boy. We are better because of him. Baby boy is an unstoppable force... just ask his sister. Happy 3rd birthday sweet boy! ...

35 3

This was probably my favorite birthday party to date. When I thought of the possibility of having it at @cabelas I immediately set my sights on it. @ben_bdoxey was hesitant and unsure but even he admitted to it being the BEST time 🌲🐾🦡🦌🌲🐾🦡🦌🌲🐾🦡
Printable scavenger hunt, invitations, thank you tags, party favor labels and banner will be available to download. Party details and availability coming soon!

30 5

Check out the Wildlife Adventure Party pack! My little boys birthday party @cabelas inspired it all! Guests went on a bingo scavenger hunt to earn their tokens for the shooting range! Party details and, printables will be hitting the website soon! #staytuned ...

29 5

Couldn’t let the day pass without wishing @ben_bdoxey the happiest of birthdays. My greatest blessing. My biggest support. My best friend. My answer to prayers. My dream come true. My perfect balance. My missing piece. My Bible dictionary. My word of the day. My recommended song. My voice of reason. I love you, and the life we are creating 💛 No matter where this life takes us, or what is achieved, or not, it will always be an abundance of “enough” with you. ...

69 7

Little Lovie’s first princess party with her cutest cousins💕 Lovie picked between an Ariel dress and a Tinkerbell dress she beelined to the pixie... 🧚‍♂️ Which is fitting because she’s the tiniest little pixie we know 💕🍋 Also, I’ll snag the information of Princess Belle 🌹 she was AMAZING! ...

39 5

“She was beautiful, but not like those girls in the magazines. She was beautiful, for the way she thought. She was beautiful, for the sparkle in her eyes when she talked about something she loved. She was beautiful, for her ability to make other people smile, even if she was sad. No, she wasn't beautiful for something as temporary as her looks. She was beautiful, deep down to her soul. She is beautiful.” I love this quote that many attribute to F. Scott Fitzgerald, but did you know there’s actually no evidence to him ever writing or saying anything like it! Either way this saying is BEAUTIFUL💕 this large print will hit the shop soon, visit for more info🍋 ...

36 13

Chasing that last bit of fall with my favorites. Cornbelly’s did not disappoint! WOW. Have you ever been? ...

33 0

#handmadehalloween Costume details and tutorials hitting the website soon! Each year I wonder why I think I need to make our costumes, only to love the finished product so much that I’ll dare to do it again next year 👻 ...

28 3
This error message is only visible to WordPress admins

Warning: The account for teachingonlemonlane, livingonlemonlane and onlemonlane needs to be reconnected.
Due to Instagram platform changes on March 2, 2020, this Instagram account needs to be reconnected to allow the feed to continue updating. Reconnect on plugin Settings page